Favorite
  • Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream
  • Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 1
  • Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 2
  • Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 3
  • Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 4
  • Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 5
  • Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 6
12
Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream
12
Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 1
Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 2
Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 3
Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 4
Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 5
Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints by Graeter's Ice Cream - Alternate image 6
Graeter's Ice Cream
Graeter's Ice Cream
97% love this shop
Star Shipper

Ice Cream - Choose Your Own 12 Pints

Ships Nationwide in U.S.Not eligible for shipping to Canada

Graeter’s ships its legendary ice cream nationwide on Goldbelly! Now you can choose up to 12 pints of Graeter’s famous handcrafted French Pot ice cream. So what will it be? Their famous Black Raspberry Chip that Cincinnati magazine named one of the foods that “defines” the city of Cincinnati? Or, maybe Madagascar Vanilla Bean that is anything but plain.

150 years and four generations later and Graeter’s is still making ice cream as they did in 1870, and it’s some of Cincinnati’s best and most beloved ice cream. Home to the world’s only French Pot Freezer, Graeter’s uses this old-school machinery to churn out their custard-like ice cream 2 gallons at a time. Every flavor starts with a French-style ice cream base made with eggs and fresh local dairy with 18% butterfat – that’s nearly double standard ice cream! While Bob Graeter admits that the French Pot process is “not the most efficient way to make ice cream” it’s worth it because it makes superb ice cream with a dense, flavorful, and unique creamy texture. Talk about artisanal!

This package includes your choice of 12 pints of Ice Cream

Flavor Options Include

  • Black Cherry Chocolate Chip – Graeter’s makes this indulgent flavor by pairing sweet dark cherries from the Pacific Northwest with their gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
  • Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip – An All-Time Best-Seller, and an absolute “must-try” for anyone new to Graeter’s. This signature flavor is made with black raspberries from Oregon’s Willamette Valley and gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips
  • Buckeye Blitz® Chocolate Chip – Chocolate peanut butter ice cream, peanut butter cookie dough and Graeter’s signature dark chocolate chips
  • Butter Pecan – With a generous amount of roasted, buttered, and salted fancy pecans, this Butter Pecan ice cream is one of the most luxurious flavors
  • Chocolate Chip – Graeter’s makes this quintessential American Classic profound by pouring their gourmet bittersweet chocolate into a spinning pot of sweet cream flavored with pure Madagascar vanilla extract
  • Chunky Chunky Hippo – Crafted to celebrate Graeter’s favorite family destination, the Cincinnati Zoo. With a toffee ice cream base, salted roasted peanuts, and milk chocolate caramel truffles, this chunky flavor is bound to be a favorite for adults and peanut-loving children alike. The best part is a portion of proceeds benefit the Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden
  • Coconut Chocolate Chip – Escape to a tropical paradise of frozen delight, combining flakes of grated coconut and gourmet bittersweet chocolate
  • Cookie & Cream – Chunks of America’s favorite sandwich cookies dunked into Graeter’s sweet ice cream will delight every child, including the one inside you!
  • Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip – Graeter’s classic vanilla base loaded with bits of cookie dough and signature dark chocolate chips
  • Dark Chocolate Brownie – A chocolate lover’s delight, this ice cream is packed with soft, chewy brownie bits complementing the richness of the dark chocolate ice cream. Can you really have too much chocolate?
  • Double Chocolate Chip – A decadent duet of Dutch cocoa powder and gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips will satisfy even the most demanding chocoholic
  • Dutch Milk Chocolate – Graeter’s sourced the very finest European cocoa to produce a smooth and sophisticated milk chocolate that is unrivaled.
  • Lemon Sorbet – Bright and light, this Lemon Sorbet is a refreshing cool respite from the hottest summer day
  • Madagascar Vanilla Bean – There is nothing plain about this vanilla. Sourced from the Bourbon Isle, off the coast of Madagascar, the fresh ground vanilla beans used are considered the world’s finest
  • Mint Chocolate Chip – Pure Peppermint Oil provides a blast of minty freshness that is pure perfection when matched with gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips
  • Mocha Chocolate Chip – Made with a proprietary blend of dark roasted Colombian and Sumatran Arabica coffee beans, mixed with fresh sweet cream then made sublime with the addition of gourmet bittersweet chocolate
  • Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip – A combination of peanut butter ice cream and milk chocolate chips puts a frozen spin on one of America’s favorite treats that is sure to please kids and adults alike
  • Oregon Strawberry – Graeter’s uses a special variety of strawberry grown on family farms in Oregon’s Willamette Valley that are selected to retain their fresh-picked flavor and color, even when frozen into ice cream.
  • Original Salted Caramel – This is one of Graeter’s original flavors that they first made over a century ago, and still do by cooking brown sugar and cream with a pinch of salt. Simple, subtle, and sublime
  • Raspberry Sorbet – Fresh, juicy red raspberries make this the sorbet-lover’s sorbet
  • Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip – Crafted by cooking brown sugar and cream with a pinch of salt, even more, decadent with the addition of gourmet, signature dark chocolate chips
  • S’Mores – This ice cream captures the essence of this campfire tradition by adding Graeter’s signature milk chocolate chips and soft mini marshmallows to a rich creamy graham cracker ice cream. A truly unique treat!
  • Toffee Chocolate Chip – classic vanilla ice cream, mix in crunchy pieces of genuine Heath® brand toffee candy, and then perfected with our gourmet milk chocolate chips!
  • Vienna Coffee – An homage to Vienna Coffee, a traditional espresso and whipped cream pairing, is brewed with a special blend of roasted Sumatran and Columbian Arabica beans