Favorite
  • Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery
  • Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 1
  • Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 2
  • Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 3
  • Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 4
  • Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 5
  • Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 6
  • Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 7
Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery
Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 1
Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 2
Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 3
Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 4
Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 5
Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 6
Cheesecake - Choose Your Own by Settepani Restaurant & Bakery - Alternate image 7
Settepani Restaurant & Bakery
Settepani Restaurant & Bakery
91% love this shop
Star Shipper

Cheesecake - Choose Your Own

Ships to U.S. & CanadaSome restrictions apply

Take your pick between all of Settepani’s delicious cheesecake flavors!

Italian-born chef Nino Settepani purchased his first bakery in Manhattan while still a student at NYU. After graduating, he perfected his craft at the French Culinary Institute. He opened a traditional Italian bakery, Settepani, in Brooklyn’s Williamsburg neighborhood in 1992, and it was such a success that a second location has been serving Harlem since 2000. Settepani has become more than just a restaurant or bakery; it’s a community gathering place where people come together to enjoy traditional Italian breads, pastries, cannoli, cakes, cookies, and more made with all-natural, organic ingredients.

This package serves 8-10 people and includes your choice of Cheesecake

  • Each cheesecake measures approx. 10" and weighs approx. 2 lbs.

Options Include

  • Classic American – A signature light, airy, creamy cheesecake – something that tastes so incredible, you’ll think it’s a dream!
  • Italian – The Italian cheesecake is just as delicious as a classic American cheesecake, with a delightful twist – they use ricotta instead of cream cheese! This is a must-try for cheesecake lovers everywhere.
  • Carrot – A signature light, airy, creamy carrot cheesecake – something that tastes so incredible, you’ll think it’s a dream!
  • Red Velvet – A signature light, airy, creamy red velvet cheesecake – something that tastes so incredible, you’ll think it’s a dream!
  • Oreo – This decadent dessert combines the classic flavor of creamy cheesecake with the irresistible crunch of Oreo cookies. Every bite is a delicious indulgence that satisfies the sweet tooth. It’s a perfect dessert for any occasion, from family dinners to special celebrations, and it’s sure to be a crowd-pleaser.
  • Rainbow Cookie – This delightful treat combines two all-time favorite Settepani specialties: American Cheesecake & traditional Italian rainbow cookies. It’s a match made in heaven!