Favorite
  • Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy
  • Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy - Alternate image 1
  • Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy - Alternate image 2
  • Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy - Alternate image 3
  • Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy - Alternate image 4
3.5 lbs
Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy
3.5 lbs
Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy - Alternate image 1
Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy - Alternate image 2
Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy - Alternate image 3
Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs. by Minerva Dairy - Alternate image 4
Minerva Dairy
Minerva Dairy
97% love this shop

Butter Party Assortment - 3.5 lbs.

Ships Nationwide in U.S.Not eligible for shipping to Canada

Minerva Dairy ships its insanely delicious Amish butter nationwide on Goldbelly! This is the original Amish Roll Butter, butter-ly delicious 85% butterfat butter churned by the batch using naturally-cultured cream.

Back in 1894, 21-year-old Max Radloff founded a dairy operation at Hustiford Creamery in Wisconsin. Throughout the early 1900s, he continually expanded his business before consolidating it to two—Hustiford, Wisconsin, and Minerva Dairy’s present location in Minerva, Ohio. For the last 120-plus years, Minerva Dairy, America’s oldest family-owned creamery, has relied on farm-fresh milk, old-fashioned churns, and wholesome ingredients to produce their award-winning cheeses and famous 85% Batch Churned Amish Butter. Today, fifth-generation siblings Adam Mueller and Venae Watts run the show, having worked at the dairy since they were 12. Their 12 kids are also beginning to learn the ropes.

This pack serves 30+ people and includes

  • Sea Salt Butter Roll (2 lbs.)
  • Garlic Herb Butter (8 oz.)
  • Everything Bagel Butter (8 oz.)
  • Lemon Poppyseed Butter (8 oz.)
  • Each item arrives individually sealed