30% OFF CRAB SALE!
King Crab, Crab Bombs & More – Ends 7/23! SHOP NOW
Favorite
Buffalo Chicken Pie
$79.95
Free Shipping
Quantity:
Get it this Tues
or check out other possible delivery dates
Gift this via EmailSend instantly or schedule for a specific time and date
Ships Nationwide in U.S.
Not eligible for shipping to CanadaOne of Centerville Pie Co’s latest and greatest creations…The Buffalo Chicken Pie. Each pie is stuffed with slow-cooked, hand-pulled chicken and buffalo sauce.
In 2009, longtime friends Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley decided to leave their careers behind as a deputy sheriff and a banker to open a pie shop. But not just any pie shop. The Pie Ladies, as they’re now known, are handcrafting what many believe to be the best chicken pie in the nation. At the top of their list of fans is none other than Oprah who discovered Centerville’s pies while on the Cape several years back and helped to elevate their pies to celeb status with a feature on her show as one of her favorite things.
This package serves 6-8 people and includes a Buffalo Chicken Pie
- Each pie measures 9"
- Pies arrive uncooked
- Pies are unbaked and shipped frozen with dry ice, may dissipate during transit.
- Upon arrival, place pie in the freezer until ready to enjoy.
To Serve
- Preheat oven to 350°F.
- Remove plastic wrap and place pie on a cookie sheet.
- Bake pie on the bottom rack for 90 minutes or until golden brown (internal temperature should reach 165 degrees).
- Remove from oven and allow pie to cool.
- Slice and enjoy!
Recommended for you
- Joe's Pick
Shepherd's Pie$79.95Free Shipping - 4
Brown Butter Honey Pecan Little Pie - 4 Pack$59.95Free Shipping 
B-More Pies93%Hot Potato Pie$74.95- Joe's Pick
The Lord of the Pies - Deep Dish Apple Pie$109.95 - 12
Choose Your Own Knishes (Kosher) - 12 Pack$119.95Free Shipping 
Double Crust Cherry Pie (Vegan)$69.95Free Shipping- Joe's Pick3 Pizzas
Heggies Famous Six Pack® Pizza - 3 Pizzas$99.95Free Shipping 
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie$75.95Free Shipping
Big Mama Box | TurDucKen + Stuffed Chicken + Boudin$289.95Free Shipping- 16
Jimmy Buff's95%Famous New Jersey Italian Hot Dog - 16 Pack$159.95Free Shipping - 18
Choose Your Own Tropical Mini Bundt Cake - 18 Pack$104.95Free Shipping - 8
Pat's Original Philly Cheesesteak - 8 Pack$199.95Free Shipping 
Kreuz Sausage Combo Dozen$125.95- 8
The Giant MacGregor Biscuit - Gluten Free$84.95Free Shipping - 8
Wood Fired Pizza 8 Pack$179.95Free Shipping - 3
Loaf Cake - Choose Your Own 3 Pack$54.95
More from MA
- CHOOSE2
Choose Your Own Pie 2 Pack$119.95Free Shipping - 12
Chicken Pies - 12 Pack$104.95Free Shipping - 8
Grilled Specialty Sandwich 8 Pack$289.95Free Shipping - 4 Qts
Clam Chowder + Lobster Bisque Combo - 4 Qts$99.95Free Shipping - 1 lb
Chocolate Dipped Biscotti$20.00per lb. - 8
Crab Cakes - 8 Pack$159.95$119.95Free ShippingSale - 3+2
Donut + Apple Fritter Combo - 5 Pack$69.95Free Shipping - SERVES2
Pasta Dinner for 2 - Choose Your Own$79.95Free Shipping - SERVES6-8
Chicken Noodle Soup$44.95Free Shipping 
Pineapple and Coconut Welsh Cakes - 3 Pack$49.95Free Shipping- 1.5 lbs each10
1.5 lb. Lobsters - 10 Pack$469.95Free Shipping 
Gluten-Free Carrot Cheesecake$89.95Free Shipping- Joe's Pick
JFK's Wedding Cake$89.95Free Shipping - SERVES4
Lobster Roll Kit - 4 Pack$169.95Free Shipping - SERVES2-4
Signature Filet Mignon + Lobster Tail + Shrimp Cocktail for 2-4$229.95Free Shipping - 6
July 4th Doughnut Cake Pops - 6 Pack$49.95Free Shipping
Customer Reviews of Centerville Pie Co.
94% love this shop. Our reviews are 100% verified customer purchases. To learn more, visit our FAQ page.
For this Product (2)
Oh My God was this outstanding. Nothing but lots of chicken and flavor!!! The crust is to die for (maybe because Nana swore by brushing with copious amounts of REAL BUTTER before baking).
Richard C.
Otisfield, ME/February 15, 2025/Verified Purchase
Everything from the ordering to the delivery to our bellies! The packaging was more than expected - everything was well packed and cushioned appropriately.
Sharon B.
Stamford, CT/December 26, 2021/Verified Purchase
