Favorite
4
4
Cookies and Cream Gelato - 4 Pints
$84.95
Quantity:
This item will be available soon
Gift This via Email/SMSSend instantly or schedule for a specific time and date
Ships Nationwide in U.S.
Not eligible for shipping to CanadaThis Southern-style Cookies and Cream Gelato is made with local grass-fed milk and cream, vanilla, and plenty of Oreo Cookies!
Sweet Magnolia Gelato Co. founder Hugh Balthorp grew up in Washington, D.C., and after marrying his wife Erica in 2000 they decamped to her native Mississippi to raise their family. He soon realized that he had a knack for making ice cream, and after teaching himself the fine art of gelato he opened Sweet Magnolia in 2011 and the crowds haven’t let up since. At Sweet Magnolia, Balthorp uses locally-sourced farmers market ingredients and grass-fed milk & cream from a local family-run dairy farm to turn out gelato that’ll make your jaw drop. It’s supremely rich and creamy, with plenty of love and lots of Southern soul in every batch.
This package includes 4 Pints of Cookies and Cream Gelato
- Gelato ships frozen with dry ice
- Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
- Dry Ice may dissipate in transit
- Upon arrival remove packaging and place immediately in the freezer
- Gelato may be stored in the freezer for 6 months
Recommended for you
- 4
Gelato Best Sellers - 4 Pints$89.95Free Shipping 
Toasted Rice Ice Cream - 6 Pints$104.95Free Shipping- 6
Valrhona Chocolate Meringue Topped Ice Cream - 6 Pints$99.95Free Shipping - 6 Pints
Cookie & Cream Ice Cream - 6 Pints$84.95 - 6
Cookie Crush Ice Cream - 6 Pints$99.95Free Shipping - SERVES2
Wild Shrimp & Cognac with Creole Cream Cheese Grits$89.95 - 12
Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies - Choose Your Own 12 Pack$79.95 - 6
Choose Your Own Ice Cream - 6 Pints$109.95Free Shipping 
Wild Blueberry "Bake-at-Home" Pie$85.95Free Shipping- SERVES10-12
White Chocolate King Cake Bread Pudding + Vanilla Custard Sauce$79.95Free Shipping - 12
Salted Caramel Chocolate Cookies - 12 Pack$39.95Free Shipping - SERVES4
Highway Inn97%Hawaii-Style BBQ & Purple Sweet Potato - Choose Your Own$119.95Free Shipping 
"Few Miles South" Kentucky Gift Box$199.95Free Shipping
Broccoli Cheddar Pot Pie$79.95Free Shipping- CHOOSE6 or 12
Patriot Decorated Butter Cookies$39.95
More from MS
Sugaree's96%"Icing Spatula" T-Shirt$25.00
Fire and Ice Pickles$69.95Free Shipping- Joe's PickSERVES10-12
Whole Smoked Turkey$159.95Free Shipping 
Sugaree's96%Cream Cheese Pound Cake$49.00
Sugaree's96%Chocolate Buttercream Frosting Cake$79.00
Sugaree's96%Strawberry Cake$79.00- 9-10 lbs
Logan Farms93%Cajun Style Turkey$109.95Free Shipping - 2 Racks
BBQ Baby Back Ribs - 2 Racks$139.95Free Shipping - 8 lbs
Logan Farms93%Honey Glazed Ham - Spiral-Sliced$129.95Free Shipping - 10"
Sea-Salted Caramel Swirl Cheesecake$69.95Free Shipping - 10"
Blueberry Swirl Cheesecake$69.95Free Shipping - 3 lbs.
Logan Farms93%Boneless Sliced Honey Glazed Ham$99.95Free Shipping 
Sugaree's96%Coconut Cake$79.00- SERVES2
Sweetheart Ribeye Dinner for 2$259.95Free Shipping - SERVES4-6
Melissa's "Barbecue Showdown" Sampler$169.95Free Shipping 
Mississippi Tamales$89.95Free Shipping
Customer Reviews of Sweet Magnolia Gelato
Our reviews are 100% verified customer purchases. To learn more, visit our FAQ page.
Gift for mother in law and she said it was very good and if she's happy I'm happy
Roseann S.
Venice, FL/March 04, 2025/Verified Purchase
Flavors were delicious!!
Rachel O.
Wilmington, NC/December 28, 2024/Verified Purchase
SO Delighted with what we received!! Ordered banana pudding gelato and the order ran short for the complete order - they sent an additional container and made it a variety pack and I am Thrilled they did!! Order was on time- perfectly packed - and each container was Fantastic!! Loved Every Flavor of the Delicious Assortment!!!! So happy we got to try them all!
Susan C.
Sahuarita, AZ/December 05, 2024/Verified Purchase
Goldbelly shipping is always good, ice cream showed up with plenty of dry ice and frozen.
Brandon B.
Lakeville, MN/November 13, 2024/Verified Purchase
The ice cream tastes great. It was delivered well packaged and still frozen.
Mara M.
Astoria, NY/September 16, 2024/Verified Purchase
Delivered exactly when you said it would. I am always impressed with you guys and will keep on using you.
Christine S.
Warrenton, VA/July 22, 2024/Verified Purchase
It is very good. It arrived on time. Great gelato!
Denise B.
Rock Springs, WY/May 12, 2024/Verified Purchase
Very fresh😀 ice cream was good! Well packaged and ice cream was frozen as if I just picked it up out of the freezer! Will try other flavors in the future.
Kimberly O.
Lancaster, TX/April 20, 2024/Verified Purchase
Everything was shipped on time and packaged well. The 2 flavors that have been tried are delicious.
Mark W.
Framingham, MA/March 07, 2024/Verified Purchase
It was a gift for my son’s birthday. The gelato was excellent.
Jonathan S.
Geneva, IL/February 27, 2024/Verified Purchase
I loved the option of knowing the estimated delivery date and selecting a different date.
Christiane S.
Long Beach, CA/February 20, 2024/Verified Purchase
The gelato was delicious!
Warren O.
San Diego, CA/February 18, 2024/Verified Purchase
This was a Christmas gift to a nephew in college and he flipped! He and his roommates thoroughly enjoyed all of the flavors and only wished that I had ordered them more.
Mac M.
Mobile, AL/January 09, 2024/Verified Purchase
Great quality and fast shipping
Lamont C.
Reidsville, NC/January 05, 2024/Verified Purchase
The order arrived on time and was still frozen. Everything was packed well by the company and labeled. The ice cream is sooooo delicious, I am very satisfied!!!
lynnelle b.
Chicago, IL/December 27, 2022/Verified Purchase
Ease of order
Bill M.
Savannah, GA/December 24, 2022/Verified Purchase
great product
Gerald P.
Milledgeville, GA/December 05, 2022/Verified Purchase
Very good vanilla flavors. I am an aficionado of vanilla. It should taste like the vanilla we used to hand churn. This is close.
Gloria B.
Eastvale, CA/October 31, 2022/Verified Purchase
Delivered frozen and on time. Excellent taste and flavors, packed well also.
Christopher F.
Moscow, ID/October 31, 2022/Verified Purchase
The pizzas are wonderful and we’re still frozen when I received them
Christopher L.
Granada Hills, CA/February 19, 2022/Verified Purchase
The pecan Kringle was so amazing. I’m always excited to order from this company. I’ve ordered a Kringle from several other bakeries but they are not the delicious goodness that O&H bakeries deliver. Not even close.
Phyllis C.
Damascus, GA/February 13, 2022/Verified Purchase
Ordering and delivery went well and the gelato was to die for!!!
JOYCE M.
Lake Frederick, VA/January 31, 2022/Verified Purchase
The pints arrived on time and safely frozen. Probably will order them again.
Angela G.
Brookhaven, NY/January 02, 2022/Verified Purchase
Once again delivery was spot on!
Joe L.
Gilbert, AZ/January 01, 2022/Verified Purchase
Very nice! Gelato came frozen and packed well. Delicious flavors!
Mary G.
Upper Marlboro, MD/December 29, 2021/Verified Purchase
The delivery was once again perfect, received on the day and time they proposed. The gelato was still frozen and I mean frozen as you would purchase it from the purveyor at their business.
Thomas V.
Moraga, CA/December 27, 2021/Verified Purchase
Arrived on time and in perfect delectable condition
Jon Z.
Pittsford, NY/December 25, 2021/Verified Purchase
Excellent delivery, wonderful product.
George S.
Scottsdale, AZ/December 14, 2021/Verified Purchase
The gift was received and the communication about the delivery was excellent
Sam W.
Naples, FL/November 23, 2021/Verified Purchase
Fast shipping, great selection, great food!
Rozanne W.
Towanda, PA/October 04, 2021/Verified Purchase
