Favorite
  • New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's
  • New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 1
  • New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 2
  • New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 3
  • New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 4
  • New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 5
3 Pizzas
New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's
3 Pizzas
New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 1
New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 2
New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 3
New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 4
New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack by Mother Kelly's - Alternate image 5
Mother Kelly's
88% love this shop

New York Pizza - Choose Your Own 3 Pack

Ships to U.S. & Canada

Some restrictions apply

Mother Kelly’s ships its famous New York Style Pizza nationwide on Goldbelly! Get your choice of three of Mother Kelly’s classic pizzas to make at home! Options include Classic New York Style Cheese Pizza that has a light and crispy crust and is topped with loads of whole milk mozzarella and the Long Island restaurant’s signature homemade marinara sauce; Signature Pepperoni Pizza, a classic New York-style cheese pizza generously topped with juicy pepperoni slices; and crave-worthy Creamed Spinach Pizza, which features a classic New York-style dough topped with heaps of whole milk mozzarella, fresh garlic, and loads of rich and creamy creamed spinach (the fancy steakhouse kind). Choose wisely, pizza lover!

Since opening in Cedarhurst, New York, in 1969, Mother Kelly’s has become a go-to Italian restaurant for in-the-know Long Islanders. Mother Kelly’s is famous for its Italian classics like balsamic chicken, garlic knots, and creamed spinach pizza. Warning…these made-from-scratch menu items are seriously addictive!

This package serves 6-9 people and includes 3 Pizzas, your choice

  • Each pizza serves 2-3 people and measures 14"

Pizza Options Include

  • Cheese
  • Pepperoni
  • Creamed Spinach
  • Pizzas ship frozen with ice packs, may thaw in transit.
  • Upon arrival, store pizzas in the refrigerator or in the freezer.
  • Pizzas last up to 2 days in the refrigerator or up to 1 month in the freezer.

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 425°F.
  • Place pizza directly on center oven rack and bake pizza for 10-12 minutes.
  • Remove from oven and enjoy!
View Full Instructions