Favorite
  • Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza
  • Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 1
  • Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 2
  • Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 3
  • Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 4
  • Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 5
  • Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 6
  • Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 7
2 Pizzas
Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza
2 Pizzas
Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 1
Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 2
Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 3
Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 4
Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 5
Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 6
Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack by Matthew's Pizza - Alternate image 7
Matthew's Pizza
Matthew's Pizza
83% love this shop

Best Seller Baltimore-Style Pizza - 2 Pack

Ships to U.S. & Canada

Some restrictions apply

This pack includes two of Matthew’s famous Baltimore-style pizzas: The Two-Cheese and Famous Crab Pie! The handmade crust is pressed into an oiled cast iron pan, and it bakes up thick, puffy, and almost focaccia-like, with a crunchy outer crust and a massive amount of stretchy, lightly browned cheese on top.

Founded by Neapolitan immigrant Matthew Cacciolo and his son Frank in Baltimore’s Highlandtown neighborhood way back in 1943, Matthew’s Pizza is a Baltimore landmark and the city’s oldest pizzeria. If you’ve never had Baltimore-style pan pizza, Matthew’s is the best place to experience it, either topped with mozzarella, Reggianito, or both; or their signature Crab Pizza, topped with cheese, onion, a sprinkle of Old Bay, and plenty of fresh Maryland crab.

This package serves 2-4 people and includes 2 Baltimore-Style Pizzas

  • Each pizza measures 10" and weighs approx. 18 oz.

Pizza Flavors Include

  • 1 “The Two-Cheese” – Tomato sauce, grated mozzarella & Reggianito cheeses
  • 1 “Famous Crab Pie” – Maryland backfin crab, grated mozzarella & Reggianito cheeses, sweet onion, Old Bay (no sauce)
  • Pizzas ship frozen with ice packs, may thaw during transit.
  • Upon arrival, store pizza in the refrigerator or in the freezer.
  • Pizzas lasts up to 2 days in the refrigerator and up to 14 days in the freezer.

To Serve

  • Thaw 1 hour before heating.
  • Preheat oven to 500° F.
  • Place in the center rack and cook for approx. 8 mins (watch your pie as all ovens differ)
  • Serve and enjoy!
View Full Instructions